When Truman Capote wrote ‘Breakfast at Tiffany’s’, he couldn’t have imagined it would kickstart the world’s love affair with Tiffany but, when was brought to the big screen, the US brand became the byword for effortless style. 

Every aspect of the brand has been positioned to grab attention in the most subtle manner that bridges the old money-new money gap while mixing sleek minimal and modernist designs with a New York heritage that stretches back to 1837. Instantly recognisable for its aquatic turquoise brand colour, its own Pantone colour, Pantone 1837, Tiffany has long been an adored and highly coveted brand. 

    

Is Tiffany Worth the Price?

The Tiffany and Co price tags are high – and rightly so. Every piece is crafted with only the highest standards of precious metals and gemstones used. In fact, Tiffany jewellers are so specific about the diamonds they use, their diamond grading standards set the benchmark for diamond quality globally.  
 
Wearing Tiffany signals your style credentials, however there is greater depth to this jewellery brand. Celebrity ambassadors are carefully curated for their star power, but also for their excellence in their field, which creates a sense of both inspiration and aspiration for brand fans to connect with. 
 
Tiffany’s designers – and design partnerships – are smart. Iconic designs, including Elsa Peretti’s collections, are the perfect way to celebrate one of life’s milestones, but the jewellery can also be worn every day. Far from a utility brand, Tiffany is also known for its devotion to romance with the Tiffany engagement ring coveted by brides-to-be across the world. 

   

Can Tiffany Ever be Affordable Jewellery?

Yes, visiting Tiffany’s flagship store at 727 Fifth Avenue in New York is only one way of buying Tiffany. Here, you’ll get the full brand experience, rather than Tiffany deals.  
 
However, there are several different options that can let you access affordable Tiffany jewellery. Preowned Tiffany pieces can be more affordably sourced from resellers, both online and in-person 

  1. Jewellers 

  1. Auction houses, including Sotheby’s 

  1. Online marketplaces, including eBay and Vinted 
     

   

How to Make Tiffany and Co Affordable?

Whether you’re seeking affordable Tiffany gifts for family and friends or sourcing vintage Tiffany jewellery, the easiest way to access cheap Tiffany and Co jewellery is to shop second hand Tiffany jewellery. 
 
What are the pros and cons of buying second hand Tiffany jewellery? How can you tell if it’s a fake?  
Where can you secure the best deals on Tiffany jewellery without compromising on condition? 

Where can you buy Tiffany jewellery?  

Pros  

Cons 

Auction houses 

Reputable, usually authenticated 

Auction premiums added, no returns 

Jewellers 

Authentication included, resizing and warranty services  

Retail mark up, quick stock rotation 

Online Market places 

Reduced prices, some can authenticate 

Increased risk of fakes, condition uncertain 

 

Exploring reputable jewellers that are known for selling affordable, preowned jewellery is a great starting place in your quest for cheap Tiffany jewellery. Jewellers will work with you to understand if you seek a particular piece or are working on securing part of a certain collection.  
 
Good jewellers will also be able to authenticate pieces, often providing certification of purchase and original boxing. This is not only important for your initial investment, but also key if you decide to resell your Tiffany jewellery in the future.  

  

Affordable Tiffany Jewellery vs Fake Tiffany Jewellery

This is a hugely important part of finding affordable Tiffany jewelleryit’s making sure that you are actually buying the real Tiffany brand and not a really good fake. 

 cheap tiffany jewellery

Real Affordable Tiffany Jewellery at S&R Jewellers

How Can I Tell if Tiffany Jewellery is Real?

Jewellers will look for certain tells when they first view any piece of Tiffany jewellery. 

How does the Tiffany piece look? 

  • Can they see “Tiffany & Co” engraved? 

  • Is the Tiffany font sharp, even, without blurring, deep and correctly spelt? 

  • Is the metal purity mark present and correct: PT950/platinum, 750/18k gold, .925/sterling silver? 

  • Are any gemstones bright, pure and well-cut? 

  • If modern, is there a unique serial number engraved? 

How does the Tiffany piece feel? 

  • Is the piece solid, heavy and substantial? 

  • Is the piece highly polished and smooth, without snags or rough surfaces? 

  • Are clasps and hinges robust and in good working order? 

  • Is every single link in necklaces and bracelets soldered, rather than simply squeezed shut? 

How does the brand packaging look and feel? (a guide rather than absolute proof) 

  • Is the box Tiffany Blue with a white satin ribbon? 

  • Is the protective pouch a high-quality suede or felt? 

What documentation is available? 

  • Does a diamond piece come with a Tiffany Diamond Certificate? 

  • Is the original receipt or purchase documentation available? 

   

Can Affordable Tiffany Jewellery be Too Good to be True?

Yes, it really can be. While there is every chance that you could strike lucky and come across affordable Tiffany jewellery for resale because of a divorce, or because someone is seeking to release the value in their Tiffany jewellery at high speed, very cheap Tiffany could very likely be fake.

    

Which Tiffany Collections are More Affordable?

Tiffany’s gemstone collections can be staggeringly expensive, but if you’re hoping to source affordable Tiffany, then the sterling silver ranges are a great place to start. ‘Return to Tiffany’ and Elsa Peretti’s ‘Open Heart’ or ‘Bean’ pendants are accessible, with preowned pieces available from £250 upwards.

    

What Am I looking for Price-wise When it Comes to Buying Preowned Tiffany Jewellery? 
 

Tiffany Piece  

Tiffany Price from new  

Preowned price 

Tiffany Setting 1886 Engagement Ring  

£4000 - £6000 

£2500-£4000 

Elsa Peretti Open Heart Pendant 

£600-£900 

£600-£800 

Tiffany T Bracelet  

£1500-£2500 

£2000-£2200 

Return to Tiffany Heart Tag Necklace 

£600-£800 

£400-£700 

 

Please note: many of Tiffany’s pieces are priced according to size and are customisable, so the ‘from new prices show a range. The average price of a Tiffany engagement ring is £4000, but actual price depends on setting, carat size and metal. 

    

Summary 

With such beautiful designs and iconic cultural links, it’s clear that Tiffany & Co remains a highly desirable brand, even if it attracts a hefty price tag. 
 
There are ways in which buyers can find affordable Tiffany jewellery by perusing preowned options. Buying second hand Tiffany does need careful consideration to make sure that buyers are shopping authentic pieces from auction houses or, for more affordable Tiffany jewellery, reputable jewellers.  

Buying cheap Tiffany jewellery is very different from buying fake Tiffany, with our guide to what-to-look-for sharing details on metal markings and boxing tells. 

Finally, our guide to preowned prices and popular Tiffany collections shared some ideas of where to start shopping for second hand Tiffany jewellery so you can start building your own affordable Tiffany collection. 

Sell Tiffany Jewellery

Read our similar article on finding affordable Cartier jewellery.

View our pre-loved range

Shop pre-loved jewellery by Bvlgari, Cartier, Tiffany, Boodles, De Beers and more

Wanting to part exchange or sell?

If you have a luxury watch or jewellery to sell directly or on consignment, or if you are interested in part exchanging for this or other items, please get in touch for a valuation.

Can't find what you are looking for?

If there is a specific watch model or jewellery piece you are looking for, then please get in touch to register your interest and be the first to see what's new.