De Beers Vs Tiffany Jewellery

We know that choosing the right jewellery is much more than just choosing a beautiful piece. It’s about resonating with a brand shaped by heritage, craftsmanship and styling. It’s about connecting with the emotional significance behind each item. Two of the world’s most prestigious jewellery names stand out as iconic brands - De Beers and Tiffany & Co. – having defined the landscape that has shaped the industry for over a century.

Discover the different aspects of each brand, showing you what to look out for from each jewellery house and help you to assess, of the two powerhouses, which brand of jewellery is best for you. Whether it's De Beers’ authority on diamonds or Tiffany’s iconic branding, we’ll review De Beers Vs Tiffany and explore how you can connect with the values behind the beauty.

De Beers Vs Tiffany – Meet the Brands

Looking at De Beers Vs Tiffany, it’s clear that both brands can be counted among the best jewellery brands in the world. Founded in 1888, De Beers is synonymous with the diamond industry, its practices, mining, and distribution, and has coined one of the best marketing slogans of all time, ‘A Diamond is Forever’. Tiffany & Co. was established half a century earlier and focuses on design and artistry, branding and luxury, forever woven into popular culture through the Hollywood classic ‘Breakfast at Tiffany’s’. Tiffany’s is a brand beloved by many, including celebrities who love Tiffany jewellery, and boasts a stellar list of ambassadors.

De Beers or Tiffany Diamond Quality

Both brands place a strong emphasis on diamonds. Both Tiffany and De Beers use the GIA International Diamond Grading System, which assesses the 4Cs - Cut, Colour, Clarity and Carat. While there are many similarities for colour, clarity and carat grading, both brands take their own approach to cut.

Tiffany & Co. uses their own cut requirements, which are often stricter than GIA’s ‘Excellent’, and the brand targets bright, symmetrical stones with strong brilliance and fire. Less than 0.05% of global gem-quality diamonds meet Tiffany’s strict standards, with each gem triple-checked for suitability from initial selection and cut review to final quality control. Tiffany’s Diamond Source Initiative™ ensures full transparency for the ethical sourcing of stones.

De Beers' own diamond pipeline means that they own the end-to-end diamond process, from mine to retail, excelling in rough-to-polished transformations that reveal the beauty of the diamond. All De Beers diamonds are measured against the De Beers Institute's own standard for grading. In addition to its mining operations in Botswana, Namibia, South Africa, and Canada, which give the brand full ownership of the diamonds it mines, the De Beers Sight holder system ensures a constant supply of rough diamonds, and the brand places a strong focus on traceable, responsibly-sourced diamonds.

Deciding which jewellery brand is best is reductive when reviewing these two brands – one is not better than the other. Still, both are celebrated for the high quality and high standards of the gemstones and precious metals used, with both using platinum and 18k gold as standard. Both brands take different approaches to the design process, which results in dramatically different collections. The iconic six-prong Tiffany® Setting places a clear focus on the central stone and is driven by timeless, heritage-driven aesthetics. De Beers’ innovative setting techniques include their micro-pavé system, and their design themes often capture natural beauty and light performance.

De Beers Jewellery

De Beers Vs Tiffany Jewellery Price Comparison

Although both brands represent the ultimate in luxury jewellery, they occupy different spaces in the market. Tiffany’s premium pricing leverages its Tiffany Blue box brand magic, with high global recognition, and reflects the labour-intensive nature of its production processes. Tiffany also pays a premium for ethically sourced ‘Excellent’ diamonds. Tiffany’s flagship stores and boutiques, in some of the most prestigious addresses on the planet, are well-positioned to reflect the luxury brand, but retail costs will impact the overall Tiffany price. Tiffany and Co. prices may often be higher than De Beers because of its cultural notoriety and its iconic packaging. Instantly recognisable, buyers are more willing to pay higher price tags because they want the ‘Tiffany experience’, from walking through the store doors to the buying process. Although Tiffany is often seen to come with a high price tag, there are some more affordable Tiffany jewellery collections for buyers looking to spend less but still own a piece of Tiffany luxury jewellery.

De Beers’ premium is more closely aligned with the provenance of their gemstones and their mining operations. With sourcing firmly in De Beers’ control, they can set their own pricing structure. As with Tiffany, De Beers’ prices reflect the craftsmanship, which can often be clearly evidenced through the precision-driven pavé process, which requires a large number of tiny stones to be set accurately.  Unlike Tiffany’s highly visible retail footprint, De Beers focuses on smaller stores that target the luxury retail experience. De Beers prices can vary based on the types of gemstones. The Talisman collection primarily features rough diamonds, which is reflected in the costs. Other collections place greater emphasis on the artistry rather than diamond size, which can also impact pricing. The De Beers brand also targets a range of customer segments, with both ultra-high-end pieces for luxury buyers and more affordable, accessible collections on offer.

Long-Term Value and Resale Insight 

Key players among the world’s best designer jewellery brands, both Tiffany and De Beers, tend to retain their value at resale as iconic diamond-led brands with strong design credentials. As with jewellery from all luxury brands, jewellery will typically be resold for less than its retail price because of brand mark-ups, but brand power can support a substantial resale value.

Many different factors impact resale value. The diamond quality and certification will likely not change, but market trends and global demand can dramatically impact resale values. Brand reputation will support a valuation, but it will also depend on factors related to the jewellery itself, from the condition and collectability to the provision of original paperwork, boxing and sales receipts.

The Tiffany price at resale is supported by its strong global brand recognition and trust, as well as much-loved collections, including Return to Tiffany and Tiffany T. De Beers prices at resale will reflect any high-quality diamonds used in the piece for sale and the collection and design. While De Beers may lack Tiffany’s brand recognition, it directly appeals to diamond-centric buyers.

Tiffany Jewellery

De Beers or Tiffany – Sustainability & Ethical Sourcing

Both De Beers and Tiffany are committed to transparent, ethical sourcing, though this manifests differently given their different supply chains.

De Beers’ Best Practice Principles (BPP) for ethical mining standards and majority ownership give them direct oversight of environmental, social, and labour practices and their Building Forever initiative targets community investment and biodiversity protection with carbon-neutral goals. De Beers’ proprietary Tracr™ blockchain platform tracks each stone from mine to retail.

Tiffany & Co. were one of the first major jewellers to publish full diamond sourcing transparency and uses the Diamond Source Initiative to disclose provenance of individually registered diamonds. With strict supplier standards, Tiffany’s diamonds are responsibly mined or responsibly sourced, and the brand has strong environmental commitments to renewable energy use and sustainability reporting.

Tiffany Vs De Beers - Which Brand Should You Choose? 

Deciding on Tiffany or De Beers is a great position to be in, as you’re choosing between two of the world’s greatest jewellery brands. However, you may feel that you gravitate towards one brand more than the other.

Tiffany jewellery is a globally recognised luxury brand with a strong heritage and is home to iconic designs, including the Tiffany Setting engagement ring. Its brand equity can lead to a stronger resale performance.

De Beers is a globally renowned diamond expert, with a mine-to-retail diamond pipeline, strict ethics and quality control.

Tiffany Ring (left) Vs De Beers Ring (right)

Conclusion – Which is the Best Jewellery Brand?

Both brands are well-respected global jewellery leaders, each offering the ultimate in craftsmanship, high-quality diamonds and superlative design credentials. Tiffany stands out for its iconic settings, instantly recognisable Tiffany Blue branding, and Tiffany and Co prices perform well at resale price. De Beers’ unrivalled diamond expertise, direct sourcing capabilities, ethics and traceability and refined, understated elegance set this diamond-centric brand apart from other luxury jewellery brands.

Tiffany or De Beers, whichever brand you gravitate towards, you can count on outstanding quality and good investment potential. Your final choice will ultimately rest on your personal style and your priorities, as well as the long-term value you’re hoping for.

At S&R Jewellers, we buy and sell both Tiffany and De Beers jewellery. Whether you’re expanding your collection or exploring resale options, we’re here to help you make an informed decision backed by expert guidance and excellence in customer service.

Read our similar jewellery guide on Cartier Vs Tiffany Vs Van Cleef jewellery

Sell Your Jewellery >>